How to Make Perfect Mashed Potatoes

I didn’t know this, but so many things determine whether or not your mashed potatoes will be bad, good or just perfect! Did you know you should never use the processor??? Check this out and apply!

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

45 Responses to How to Make Perfect Mashed Potatoes

  1. Pat Stapp's avatar Pat Stapp says:

    Too much trouble. I can peel, cook and mash in 20 minutes, and in over 50 years of cooking, have never had anyone complain about my mashed potatoes.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. She say all the right things, but in the video, used WAY to much cream, they are not “fluffy mashed”, they creamy mashed.

    Like

    • Stephanie's avatar Stephanie says:

      I agree, way too much cream…I don’t like “creamy” runny masher and use a hand mixer…mine are always fluffy and loved by all. Too each his own

      Like

  3. Lindsey's avatar Lindsey says:

    Those are considered creamed potatoes here in the south…

    Like

  4. Lisa's avatar Lisa says:

    Does any one use a hand mixer to mash the potatoes??

    Like

    • Ethel's avatar Ethel says:

      yes , works wit h any kind of white potatoe.ETHEL

      Like

      • SHERRY's avatar SHERRY says:

        YES, I USE A HAND MIXER TO MASH OUR POTATOES…
        I HAD AN OPERATION ON MY RIGHT HAND AND STARTED USING THE MIXER.
        MY FAMILY SAID THEY ARE THE BEST I’VE EVER MADE.

        NOW THAT MY DAUGHTER IS MARRIED, SHE WAS SURPRISED TO SEE HER HUBBY’S FAMILY USES THE MIXER TOO.

        ; )

        Like

      • angela's avatar angela says:

        I to use a mixer I boil mine til they r soft kind of fall apart then take water out then put butter mix it then put lots n lots of milk I love my mashed potatoes

        Like

    • Patricia's avatar Patricia says:

      I have used an electric mixer for 45+ years. Use red potatoes, salt while boiling, drain, add milk and butter, mix. Perfect every time!!

      Like

    • Lisy's avatar Lisy says:

      Im always using hand mixer, its also good exercise for arms lol

      Like

    • Diana Jacobs's avatar Diana Jacobs says:

      Diana says:
      Oh, yeah to the hand mixer! A top chef taught me how. Hand mash them and add your butter first, and when done, mixer, and then add milk last. Perfectly fluffy and smooth! To die for! Yummmmmmmmmmmmmmm!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

      Like

  5. all the nutrients from the potatoes are wasted and gone. it’s in the water. if the sink has a digestive system it would be the healthiest member of the family.. we should boil our potatoes cleaned and unpeeled not using too much water to save its vitamins and minerals that our body needs.. i do it the Saladmaster way…could taste the big difference… the natural sweetness of potatoes are saved. if our fruits and vegetables are already peeled off don’t wash them in water anymore.

    Like

    • Janet's avatar Janet says:

      Agree about the nutrients……..I freeze the potato water…many uses for it — broths, stews, homemade bread.

      Like

  6. Barry's avatar Barry says:

    Red skins are the best to use , cheese , very little cream warmed , and 1 raw egg & butter , salt & pepper .

    Like

  7. Lorinda Earles's avatar Lorinda Earles says:

    I’m 50yrs old and been making my mashed spuds very close to those. I use chicken broth to boil spuds in, and not so much cream.

    Like

  8. Donna Jordan's avatar Donna Jordan says:

    Use mayo instead of milk
    Soooooo much better!

    Like

  9. vikky's avatar vikky says:

    omg so wrong ! each to their own i guess ..

    Like

  10. lorraine's avatar lorraine says:

    mine always come out perfect depends on the potatoes your using just butter and milk and a good masher simple

    Like

  11. Shane's avatar Shane says:

    To make em really fluffy I whisk the potatoes and add air they are really light and fluffy and creamy

    Like

  12. Ruth's avatar Ruth says:

    Removing the skin before boiling allows much of the nutrients and vitamins to go into the water.
    The water thrown out is the best part. Leave the skins on. Wash them and boil them. You won’t have to do much peeling. The potatoes skins break open.

    Like

  13. Tootsie's avatar Tootsie says:

    I use an electric mixer, butter, up to 1/2 cup of whole milk and a hand full of shredded cheddar. Everyone needs to salt and pepper them to their liking.

    Like

  14. Jeanette Christensen's avatar Jeanette Christensen says:

    To me that is not mashed potatoes, but more like potatoes porridge… I cook mine like hers, but I poor VERY little milk and more butter in and mash them up with my Hand mixer… That gives fluffy delicious potatoes everysingle time…

    Like

  15. Ryan's avatar Ryan says:

    Meh, those are way to runny, like hungry jack box style runny. I myself and most people I know like some chunky mashed potatoes. Lots of butter, and some mile and cream, but easy on the mashing….leave some chunks for the ultimate consistency.

    Like

  16. karen's avatar karen says:

    whoa…she or he I couldn’t tell thinks far too much about potatoes plus s/he made potato cream soup, I like to eat my mashed with a fork not a spoon. two thumbs down on this recipe

    Like

  17. Kelly's avatar Kelly says:

    She did it all right except way too much cream and add more butter

    Like

  18. Vick's avatar Vick says:

    I use butter, milk , pepper,mayo and mexican cotija cheese … its delicious…

    Like

  19. Cheryl's avatar Cheryl says:

    I use sour cream and onion salt……….amazing!!!!

    Like

  20. Diana Jacobs's avatar Diana Jacobs says:

    Just goes to show ya folks! Everybody’s different! However, it’s nice to share our different ways to each other. It’s fun! Nobody does it “right” or “wrong”. They do it the way they like.

    Like

  21. Many Scandinavian meals include LOTS of butter and cream. That’s why we ‘er so sweet and smooth! 😉

    Like

  22. Barb's avatar Barb says:

    I have never made them any way but perfect and that means different every time. And yes you can over cook them to slop, that is not perfect. Everyone loves my red skinned smashed potatoes with skins left on. Secret is to add some milk, sour cream and butter. Season with garlic, salt and pepper. Anybody hungry? Perfect comfort food!

    Like

  23. Norma Hetherington's avatar Norma Hetherington says:

    Those looked absolutely horrible to me! Way too much cream and not enough butter. I hand mash and like a little chunkiness in there!

    Like

  24. This woman have lost it ……… ALL THAT CREAM!!! YEAH HEARTACHE COMES TO MIND

    Like

  25. Lori's avatar Lori says:

    I use cream cheese butter a very little milk also use an electric mixer! These are so good got the idea from friend!

    Like

  26. Anna Pinnock's avatar Anna Pinnock says:

    Almost right on I am a caterer who has trained with some amazing chefs…you should not over boil your potatoes as they become water logged. Use warmed 1/2 & 1/2 not cream. Don’t over stir as it makes mashed potatoes gluey. Or add too much cream/milk at first…you can always add more later.

    Like

Comments are closed.